Fixing a tie

Contesting a Will: Why You Need an Attorney for Complex Will Disputes


A will outlines how a deceased person intends to distribute their assets after they pass away. Will contestations arise when an interested party, such as a beneficiary or family relative, challenges the will’s validity. This occurs for several reasons, including asserting the will was signed under duress, forged or falsified, or not appropriately witnessed. 

Will contest disputes can also arise when the interpretation of a will is challenged, especially in complex cases. It is crucial to have an experienced probate lawyer help you navigate the intricacies of this process. Thus, parties involved in these proceedings should stay informed and seek legal recourse when necessary.

Understanding Complex Will Disputes

Contesting a will involves formally petitioning the court to invalidate a deceased’s will and instead distribute their assets in an alternative manner. Usually, will contests arise from family conflict and require proof the deceased improperly executed the will.

Additionally, only certain people have the standing to contest a will. These include heirs or beneficiaries named in a previous will, close family members who would receive inheritance if there were no will, and others who have a direct financial interest in the estate.

In general, will disputes occur when an interested party challenges the validity of the will for reasons including:

  • The will was not executed correctly. For example, it was not executed according to state law or adequately signed or witnessed.
  • The will was forged or falsified, meaning the document was altered or created deceptively.
  • The testator did not have the mental capacity to create the will. In other words, the testator or deceased person was not of sound mind to make legal decisions due to cognitive impairments, such as learning disabilities or dementia.
  • Someone unduly influenced the testator to make specific provisions to the will. For example, an interested party coerces a testator to include plans in the will that benefit the coercer rather than reflect the testator’s true wishes. 

Moreover, will contests are further complicated by the following circumstances:

  • Disinheriting a child or spouse. For example, when a will favors a friend, charity, or another relative over the testator’s child or spouse.
  • Unequal distribution, wherein the testator provides unequal estate shares among children or beneficiaries.
  • Abrupt and substantial modifications to a will can raise suspicions and may lead to further litigation.
  • Conditional inheritance, whereby the testator imposes strict conditions regarding when or how someone receives their inheritance.

Impact on Beneficiaries 

Furthermore, complex will disputes can have several negative impacts on beneficiaries. For example, will contest disputes involving multiple issues or contending parties can further complicate the process and delay the property distribution timeline. This may cause financial and emotional strain for those dependent on the deceased’s estate.

Will disputes can also be expensive, and beneficiaries may have to pay significant legal and court fees. This can reduce the estate’s overall value, minimizing the amount available for distribution to beneficiaries afterward. 

Likewise, these proceedings may end in a total loss of inheritance for some, which may be devastating if there are beneficiaries who depend on the deceased’s estate for financial support. For these reasons, seeking legal advice and representation from a probate lawyer is essential to protect your rights and those of your loved ones.

Understanding the Legal Process

Will disputes are complex legal matters requiring expertise in estate planning, probate law, and litigation. These disputes involve various legal issues, including contract, property, and tort law. Moreover, laws governing probate and will contestation vary by state. 

Therefore, although not required, securing an attorney who can guide you through these proceedings is highly recommended. A probate lawyer plays a crucial role in navigating the legal process, and some key advantages of hiring one include:

  • Assessing Will’s Validity: Attorneys analyze probate documents, such as a will, to determine whether they meet legal requirements by state and jurisdiction. If there are any issues with the document’s execution, an attorney can raise these concerns and challenge the will’s validity.
  • Identifying Potential Contenders: Attorneys help identify potential contenders with a legal right to challenge the will. This includes heirs, beneficiaries, or others who may have a direct financial interest in the deceased’s estate.
  • Preparing Legal Documents: Attorneys help prepare official documents, such as petitions, pleadings, and motions, that must be appropriately filed with the court and served on all interested parties. Note that these documents can be confusing to prepare without professional legal assistance.
  • Gathering Evidence: Attorneys help you locate and gather necessary evidence to support your case, such as medical records or witness statements. This can help establish a will’s validity or support claims of undue influence, fraud, or lack of capacity.
  • Representing Clients in Court: Attorneys defend your rights and argue your case before the judge. Using their extensive legal knowledge, they cross-examine witnesses, present evidence, and make legal arguments in the deceased’s best interests.
  • Negotiating Settlements: Attorneys can help negotiate a settlement with opposing parties to resolve disputes outside of court. This can help save time, money, and emotional stress for everyone involved.

It is important to emphasize the statute of limitations in probate proceedings. A time frame for contesting a will exists, and it varies by state. Typically, it is between a few months to a few years, but it can take longer depending on the dispute and other related factors.

Essentially, an attorney’s role in navigating complex will contests is to ensure their client’s rights are protected and the deceased’s wishes are carried out. Thus, choosing an adept attorney well-versed in your state’s probate laws is vital. 

Choosing the Right Attorney

When looking for an attorney to assist with complex will disputes, it is crucial to consider several qualities that set apart the best probate attorneys:

  1. Experience in estate planning, probate law, and litigation. Remember to find an attorney specializing in the state and jurisdiction where the deceased lived.
  2. Effective communication, explaining legal terms and processes in simple language that you can understand.
  3. Attention to detail is essential for complex will disputes. Your probate lawyer should be thorough in reviewing probate documents and identifying potential issues.
  4. Available and responsive to your needs. Your attorney should be accessible to answer questions and provide updates on your case’s progress.
  5. Reputable, demonstrating success in resolving complex will disputes.
  6. Cost-effective, providing transparency in billing and offering reasonable rates.

An attorney’s experience and expertise in handling complex cases is crucial in ensuring a successful outcome. You want to choose an attorney familiar with the nuances of the legal system, including court procedures, rules of evidence, and court precedents. They can leverage this knowledge to build a strong case and advocate for your rights effectively. 

Additionally, an experienced attorney can provide valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of a case, which is vital in negotiating settlements or preparing for trial. Overall, an attorney’s experience and expertise can be instrumental in navigating complex legal issues, ensuring fair and just outcomes, and protecting the deceased’s rights.

To find the right attorney, ask friends or family members for professionals they trust and have worked with. Alternatively, you can search for attorneys online by location and specialization. Remember to check reviews from past clients to gauge their experience working with the attorney. 

Finally, consider finding an attorney who offers free initial consultations where you can gain greater insight into the details of your case at no cost.


Contesting a will can be a difficult and emotionally charged experience. Legal proceedings can be challenging, lengthy, and financially burdensome. Therefore, it is crucial to secure an attorney to guide you through the process and ensure the deceased’s wishes are protected and carried out. 

Remember, having a probate lawyer on your side can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. With their help, you can increase your chances of receiving a fair distribution of the deceased’s estate and minimize the financial and emotional strain that often comes with will contestation disputes.

Legal Expertise You Can Rely On

Scroll to Top